Sunken Harbor Club
Sunken Harbor Club is an intimate nautical cocktail bar tucked away on the second floor above Gage & Tollner. After eight years as a weekly pop-up at owner St. John Frizell's Red Hook mainstay Fort Defiance, The Club finally anchored in Downtown Brooklyn in October 2021. Join us for innovative libations and refreshing new takes on classic tropical cocktails from Chief Cocktail Officer Garret Richard.
Please note that The Club does not take reservations; bar seats and tables are available on a first-come, first-served basis. Enter through Gage & Tollner and see our host to be seated.
Gage & Tollner gift certificates can be redeemed at The Club.
OPEN DAILY: 5pm-late
372 Fulton Street, 2nd FL
Brooklyn NY 11201
Eats
-
Accras de Morue
Salt-Cod Fritters, Salsa Negra
$15
-
'Ducky Lumplings'
Pork or Vegetable, Sesame Soy Dipping Sauce
$14
-
Adam's Ribs
Coconut Braised Pork Ribs, Facing Heaven Chili Crisp, Seeds
$16
Sweets
-
Miso Butterscotch Pudding
arare, whipped cream, toasted coconut
$12
gluten free
In the Shallows
Easy drinking cocktails for a pleasant moonlight swim-
Star Cycle
As weightless and ethereal as stardust itself; both otherworldly and ever familiar. Milk washed Gin, jasmine, grapefruit, and Campari. Shaken and served up.
$18
-
Yellow Tang
A tall, loveable cocktail made with vodka, banana, pineapple, and passion fruit. Served on pebble ice.
$20
-
Ship of Fools
Embark on a journey through a tempestuous realm - mezcal, sherry, cucumber, and serrano pepper unite for this daring exploit. Stirred and served up.
$18
-
Ginza Lights
Get lost in the streets of Tokyo with this highball. Yuzu and white grapefruit bring the heat to Japanese rum. Served carbonated.
$18
-
Singapore Burrapeg
This elegant Champagne cocktail is the more refined cousin of the Singapore Sling. With kirsch, Bénédictine, and a lime twist. Served up in a wine glass.
$20
-
El Diablo
Tequila teams up with raspberry, blackcurrant, and the heat of fresh ginger. Served as a highball.
$20
-
Special Daiquiri No. 2
The Holy Trinity of Caribbean mixology - rum, lime, and cane - made more refreshing with the addition of shiso. Shaken and served up.
$18
The Twilight Zone
As we go deeper, sunlight fades and the drinks get stronger-
Mai Tai
The club recipe for the Trader Vic classic, with a blend of three rums, almond, orange, and mint. (Contains nuts.) Served on pebble ice.
$20
-
Immortal Martini
This gin Martini intrigues the senses with sesame oil, red pepper, and a cooling hint of cucumber. Not as briny as the sea, but enough to evoke the ocean's mist. Stirred and served up.
$20
-
Tijuana Taxi
A delicious white Negroni with mezcal and banana, if one can believe that. Stirred and served on a big rock.
$20
-
Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner
Chief Cocktail Officer Garret expands the concept of the classic Navy Grog, with Demerara rum, kola nut, allspice, and grapefruit. Served on a pebble ice.
$20
-
Hibiscus Pacific
An icy chill may try to steal its grace, yet the hibiscus blooms in a warm embrace. Tequila and mezcal anchor this delightfully frozen Margarita with a tart finish. Served slushy.
$20
-
Suffering Bastard
A legendary reviver from Cairo. Our carefully brewed ginger beer supports this long drink of gin, Cognac, and lime. Step back in time to WWII days at Shepheard's Hotel. Served carbonated.
$20
-
Crab Key
An old-fashioned attitude adjuster worthy of Dr. No, with Scotch and macadamia nut, and coconut water. Stirred and served on a big rock.
$25
The Abyss
Our strongest drinks come from the point of no return-
Donn's Dram
A Beachcomer's Sazerac Rye, Demerara Rum, cinnamon-grapefruit cordial and Herbsaint. Stirred and served up
$18
-
High Seas Shakedown
The last draught of many enemies of pirate Roc the Brazilian, who liked to raise a glass with his victims. Javanese and Caribbean rums, French quinquina, and hot pepper-mala flavors. Served on pebble ice
$20
-
Bin-N-Gitters
A bold, icy cross between a “pink gin” and a gimlet, with lashings of angostura. Shaken and served up
$18
-
Rum Barrel
a simple name for a drink that’s anything but, anchored by a secret blend of rums, five types of citrus, allspice, and bitters, served on pebble ice in a tankard
$22
-
White Zombie
the sunken harbor club award-winning classic, with lots of white spirits, grapefruit, lime, coconut, and undead spices, served on pebble ice
$20
-
Angostura Colada
a powerful production starring a jiggerful of angostura bitters, supported by jamaican rums, pineapple, coconut, and nutmeg, now served worldwide, but first recorded by zac overman at the shc, served on pebble ice
$22
-
Grog of The Two Brothers
a muscular mix of rums from martinique and mexico, pointed up by raspberry and black pepper, served on pebble ice
$20
On Dry Land
Nonalcoholic-
Palm Tree Attack
What happens when royal palms get rowdy; with pineapple, coconut, lime, and cinnamon. Served as a highball
$8
-
Gungan
A very dry pineapple tonic with the fragrance of cardamom. Served as a highball
$8
Wine
-
Sparkling
-
Chenin Blanc
Vouvray 2017, Cuvée T, Vincent Carême
$17
$68
-
White
-
Ribolla Gialla
Friuli Colli Orientali 2019, Vigna Lenuzza
$14
$56
-
Albariño
Rias Baixas (Val do Salnes) 2019, Do Ferreiro
$18
$72
-
Skin Contact / Rosé
-
Grolleau Noir
Touraine Azay-le-Rideau 2020, Boutanche Rosé, Le Sot de l'Ange
$11
$55
-
Red
-
Baga Blend
Vinho Tinto (Portugal) 2020, Nerd Duck, Joao Pato
$14
$56
-
Malbec Blend
Cahors 2018, La Fage, Cosse & Maisonneuve
$17
$68
Beer
-
Brooklyn Lager
$9
-
Ommegang "Super Kriek" Wild Ale
$10
-
Three's "Logical Conclusion" IPA
$12
-
Rockaway "Original ESB" Bitter
$8
The Commodore’s Collection
A Note to MembersPrices represented as 1oz. / 2oz. pours
-
Père Labat Réserve Familiale
Origin—Marie-Galante (Guadeloupe) a rare rum from the island of Marie-Galante, a small Caribbean island between Guadeloupe and Dominica. Hand-cut sugarcane is slow-fermented, distilled in a creole column, and aged for six years. Exceedingly dry, with classic rhum agricole flavors.
$10
$18
-
Worth Park Single Estate Reserve
Origin~ Jamaica Made in a copper pot still at Worthy Park, then aged, blended and bottled on site. Imagine a warm kitchen with a French apple pie resting on the stove, then add a little milk chocolate, ginger, and warm tea with cream. A very polished and friendly Jamaican rum.
$11
$20
-
El Dorado Single Still Port Mourant
Origin~ Guyana This rum is produced on the world's only operating double wooden pot still, located at Guyana's Demerara Distillers Ltd.; "Port Mourant" refers to this still's original home, a sugar plantation founded in 1732. A profound earthiness provides a backdrop for flavors of butter, honey and fruitcake with a little black pepper. A true unicorn, and a perennial Club favorite.
$13
$24
-
Appleton Estate 15 Year Old Black River Casks
Origin~Jamaica Created by Appleton Estate’s legendary master blender Joy Spence, this recent release is a gift to fans of deeply aged Jamaican rums. Layers of spicy cinnamon, cooked banana, crème brulée, and ginger cookie flavors are supported by an enduring base of Jamaican “funk.”
$10
$18
-
L'Encantada Domaine de Pouy Armagnac 2001
Origin~ Tenareze, France A brawny Armagnac finished in rum casks from Jamaica's Worthy Park. Traditional Armagnac flavors of dark cherry, chocolate and tobacco dance with tropical notes of papaya and banana. To be sipped very slowly. Bottled at 57.3% ABV, this big stunner benefits from a few drops of water.
$22
$40
Sunken Harbor Club Merchandise
-
Bandana
$25
-
Enamel Mug №.1
$15